Wednesday, 9 October 2019

Attempting to communicate with the BBC: it's not just politicians who refuse to answer questions

A couple of weeks ago there was an outburst of public indignation after it emerged that the BBC had censured their presenter Naga Munchetty. As reported by the Independent, in July BBC Breakfast reported on comments made by President Trump to four US congresswomen, none of whom was white, whom he told to "go back and help fix the totally broken and crime-infested places from which they came." Naga commented "Every time I've been told as a woman of colour to 'go home', to 'go back to where I've come from', that was embedded in racism."

Most of the commentary at the time focused on whether or not Naga had behaved unprofessionally in making the comment, or whether she was justified in describing Trump's comment as racist. The public outcry has been heard: the Director General of the BBC, Tony Hall, has since overturned the decision to censure her.

There is, however, another concern about the BBC's action, which is why did they choose to act on this matter in the first place. All accounts of the story talk of 'a complaint'. The BBC complaints website explains that they can get as many as 200,000 complaints every year, which averages out at 547 a day. Now, I would have thought that they might have some guidelines in place about which complaints to act upon. In particular, they would be expected to take most seriously issues about which there were a large number of complaints. So it seems curious, to say the least, if they had decided to act on a single complaint, and I started wondering whether it had been made by someone with political clout.

The complaints website allows you to submit a complaint or to make a comment, but not to ask a question, but I submitted some questions anyhow through the complaints portal, and this morning I received a response, which I append in full below. Here are my questions and the answers:

Q1. Was there really just ONE complaint?
BBC: Ignored

Q2: If yes, how often does the BBC complaints department act on a SINGLE complaint?
BBC: Ignored

Q3: Who made the complaint?
BBC: We appreciate you would like specific information about the audience member who complained about Naga's comments but we can't disclose details of the complainant, but any viewer or listener can make a complaint and pursue it through the BBC's Complaints framework.

Q4: If you cannot disclose identity of the complainant, can you confirm whether it was anyone in public life?
BBC: Ignored

Q5: Can you reassure me that any action against Munchetty was not made because of any political pressure on the BBC?
BBC: Ignored

I guess the BBC are so used to politicians not answering questions that they feel it is acceptable behaviour. I don't, and I treat evasion as evidence of hiding something they don't want us to hear. I was interested to see that Ofcom is on the case, but have been fobbed off just as I was. Let's keep digging. I smell a large and ugly rat.

Here is the full text of the response:

Dear Prof Bishop
Reference CAS-5652646-TNKKXL
Thank you for contacting the BBC.
I understand you have concerns about the BBC Complaints process specifically with regard to a complaint made regarding Breakfast presenter Naga Munchetty and comments about US President Trump. 
Naturally we regret when any member of our audience is unhappy with any aspect of what we do. We treat all complaints seriously, but what matters is whether the complaint is justified and the BBC acted wrongly. If so we apologise. If we don’t agree that our standards or public service obligations were breached, we try to explain why. We appreciate you would like specific information about the audience member who complained about Naga's comments but we can't disclose details of the complainant, but any viewer or listener can make a complaint and pursue it through the BBC's Complaints framework.
Nonetheless, I understand this is something you feel strongly about and I’ve included your points on our audience feedback report that is sent to senior management each morning and ensures that your complaint has been seen by the right people quickly. 
We appreciate you taking the time to register your views on this matter as it is greatly helpful in informing future decisions at the BBC.
Thanks again for getting in touch.
Kind regards
John Hamill
BBC Complaints Team

2 comments:

  1. Herbal medicine is 100% guarantee for HSV and Cancer cure, the reason why most people are finding it difficult to cure HSV is because they believe on medical report, drugs and medical treatment which is not helpful to cure HSV . Natural herbs are the best remedy which can easily eradicate herpes forever. i have seen post and several people been cured and that he could provide HERBS Cure for HERPES Type 1&2 , WARTS, CANCER, ALS, Mental illness, DIABETES Disease patient, with ROOTS AND HERBS without delay Kindly contact IYOHA SOLUTION HERBAL HOME via
    website: https://driyohasolutiontemple.weebly.com
    whatsapp : +254755681540

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello everyone i am Bryan by name.I was diagnosed with herpes in 2016, i read about testimony of Dr Iyoha that i can be cured by him which I never believed because I have spend so much money on different doctors.I decided to give it a try because of the testimony of a woman he cured of Cancer with herbs. So I mailed him and complain to him about my illness, he said to me I am in the right place. Today i am the most happy person on Earth all thanks to Dr Iyoha, he cured me with a herbal medicine. All i did was to order for the herbs which he sent through courier delivery services and he instructed me on how to apply it for a period of 2weeks, before the completion of the 2nd week i was totally cured .I'm so happy all thanks to you Dr Iyoha. I share this because of the pain i passed through when i had it and i care about those passing through the same pain. He also said he has herbs for all kind of illness including HIV/AIDS, ASTHMA, CANCER, DIABETIC 1&2, BARRENNESS, IMPOTENCE, WOMB DAMAGE, HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE and EPILEPSY .Thank you doctor i will keep on telling the world about you because i am free of herpes forever.

    Email: driyohasolutiontemple@yahoo.com
    Website: https://driyohasolutiontemple.weebly.com
    Whatsapp : +254755681540

    ReplyDelete